Back to Newsletters
CMOs can stop playing defense on marketing spend by defining metrics clearly, identifying leading indicators, improving pipeline health, avoiding false attribution fights, tracking reputation, and knowing which operational metrics belong off the board slide. This preview turns CMO Huddles taskforce insights into a practical metrics reset for leaders tired of source battles and budget defense.
Marketing metrics can either clarify the growth story or turn the CMO into a courtroom defendant with a dashboard for an alibi. Too often, the conversation starts with “prove it” instead of “what should we invest in next?” That is the difference between defense and offense.
A CMO Huddles metrics taskforce featuring Heidi Bullock, Peter Finter, Jamie Gilpin, Grant Johnson, Kathie Johnson, and Bryan Law dug into the measurement mess: Overvalued metrics, nonlinear buying journeys, data overload, and the eternal temptation to make one-size-fits-all reporting do the work of actual strategy.
The goal is not more metrics. The goal is better metrics used better.
Heidi Bullock put the first requirement plainly:
“We need to make sure the definition of an opportunity is very black and white.”
This sounds obvious until Sales, Marketing, Customer Success, and Finance each bring a slightly different definition to the same meeting and everyone spends 40 minutes comparing spreadsheets like rival archaeologists.
Kathie Johnson’s team created a yearly “pipeline playbook” aligned to the CRO’s vision. That is the kind of operating discipline CMOs need. Define what counts as an opportunity, what counts as pipeline, who owns each stage, which actions influence movement, and which metrics actually signal progress.
The CMO move: Own the definitions before the definitions own you.
Revenue matters. No argument. But revenue is often a lagging indicator, which means it tells you how well decisions made months ago are performing today. Useful, yes. Sufficient, no.
Grant Johnson urged CMOs to look wider:
“Tracking metrics beyond just the pipeline funnel, like NPS, SOV, social and advocacy improve visibility into pipeline health and momentum.”
Peter Finter looked at inbound traffic conversions as a predictive measure. Bryan Law found short-term new business metrics highly indicative of future revenue. The common thread: Offense-minded CMOs measure signals that help them make smarter moves before the quarter is already cooked.
The CMO move: Build a leading-indicator set that connects reputation, demand, conversion, retention, and momentum.
Pipeline is not just a number. It is a living system with quality, age, velocity, mix, and probability. A large pipeline filled with weak opportunities is not a growth engine; it is a very confident mirage.
Heidi put it bluntly:
“Pipeline and pipeline health and scrutiny are the most important thing businesses can do.”
CMOs should understand win rate, speed to close, deal size, stage conversion, segment performance, source mix, and where opportunities are getting stuck. Then they should connect specific marketing activities to improvements in those dynamics.
The CMO move: Stop treating pipeline as a headline number. Study the mechanics underneath.
Attribution is useful until it becomes religion. In complex B2B, purchase decisions are rarely linear and rarely influenced by one or two touches. Pretending otherwise may make a dashboard look tidy, but it does not make the buying journey less messy.
Jamie Gilpin explained the webinar problem perfectly:
“When we have a webinar, for example, we have all these things that surround it so it makes it really hard to isolate the pipeline generated from the webinar alone.”
Exactly. A webinar may be supported by email, social, SDR follow-up, executive outreach, partner promotion, customer proof, paid media, and prior brand awareness. The buyer does not care which touch gets a trophy.
Grant Johnson offered the healthier frame:
“In complex B2B markets, let’s aim for ‘everyone’s pipeline,’ and avoid source battles between Marketing and Sales.”
The CMO move: Use attribution for learning and optimization, not for credit warfare.
Some executive teams still hear “brand” and immediately clutch the budget. Fine. Call it reputation if that gets everyone breathing normally again.
Reputation-related metrics can include awareness, analyst recognition, review site performance, share of voice, direct traffic, branded search, category association, customer advocacy, and sales confidence. These are not soft metrics when they shape whether buyers trust you before a rep ever appears.
Kathie Johnson suggested renaming brand activities as “ungated activities” and described forward-looking metrics as marketing “headlights.” That is useful language. Headlights do not prove you reached the destination. They help you avoid driving into something expensive.
The CMO move: Track reputation as a future-growth signal, whether or not you call it brand.
Not every useful metric belongs in the board deck. Website traffic, keyword movement, social engagement, email clicks, and content consumption can be valuable diagnostic signals. They can also become executive distractions if presented without context.
Heidi uses tools like Moz for SEO insight but would not necessarily present that data to the board. Kathie sees website visits as a leading indicator, not the main report-out metric.
That distinction is everything. CMOs need operational metrics to manage the machine and executive metrics to explain business progress. Confuse the two and someone will ask why a LinkedIn like did not become pipeline.
The CMO move: Build two layers of reporting: Operational diagnostics for the team, business signals for executives.
Moving metrics from defense to offense means using measurement to guide investment, improve collaboration, and make better decisions. It means defining terms clearly, tracking leading indicators, scrutinizing pipeline health, avoiding attribution absolutism, measuring reputation, and knowing which metrics to keep backstage.
The best metrics do not just defend marketing spend. They help CMOs invest to win.
It means using metrics to guide future investment and growth decisions instead of only defending past marketing spend.
Report metrics tied to business progress: Pipeline health, revenue movement, win rate, deal velocity, retention, reputation, and leading indicators connected to growth.
B2B buying journeys involve many people, channels, and touches. Over-crediting one source can create internal fights and misleading investment decisions.
Operational metrics like traffic, keyword rankings, email clicks, and social engagement are useful for optimization but usually need business context before executive reporting.