Back to Newsletters
Budget season does not have to be a haunted house or a spreadsheet seance. CMOs can make planning stronger by balancing people, programs, and technology; matching spend to company stage; locking growth assumptions; reverse-engineering from revenue goals; preparing incremental asks; and clarifying fragmented ownership before finance starts swinging the spreadsheet axe again at year-end, too.
It's that spooky season when the winds howl, the CFOs sharpen their pencils, and CMOs huddle over flickering spreadsheets hoping their budget proposals do not get slashed like the cast of a B-grade horror flick.
Budget season can feel haunted because the ghosts are real: Unclear forecasts, bloated headcount ratios, underfunded programs, disconnected budget owners, and the chilling executive question, “What would you do with more?” asked by someone who may or may not actually have more.
In October, CMO Huddlers and Craig Moore of Forrester shared practical ways to make budgeting less theatrical and more strategic. Here are seven lessons for CMOs who would prefer not to build next year’s plan in the fiscal crypt.
Some marketing budgets look alive because there are plenty of people attached to them. But if people costs consume the plan and program dollars disappear, the team can end up with ideas, meetings, and very little motion.
“We’re very high on people,” one CMO shared, “but without enough program dollars, I worry we’re not fueling the funnel effectively.”
Another CMO put the risk even more plainly: “You don’t want a team sitting idle because there’s no budget to activate their ideas.”
That is the zombie budget: Plenty of bodies, no momentum. CMOs do not need a universal headcount ratio. They do need enough activation budget to turn strategy into market action.
Your budget mix should change as the company changes. Like a werewolf at full moon, except with fewer villagers and more spreadsheets.
One CMO described a current allocation of 50% people, 20% tech, and 30% programs, while aiming for something closer to “a third, a third, a third.” The goal was not symmetry for symmetry’s sake. It was productivity.
“It’s a misalignment issue,” they explained. “I want a more productive team enabled by better tools.”
That is the right question: Does the mix support the work the business needs now? A mature enterprise, a PE-backed scale-up, and an early-stage category builder should not all have the same budget skeleton.
Startups may not have mummies in their closets, but they do have demand generation to resurrect. At that stage, program spend often needs to carry more weight because awareness and demand are not optional side quests.
“We’re at 65% programs because we need awareness and demand—fast,” said one CMO building a budget from the ground up.
Moore reinforced the point: “Stage of company growth should directly influence where dollars go. Don’t force-fit a mature model on an early-stage business.”
Different monsters, different weapons. The budget that works for a company defending market share may starve a company still trying to be known.
One of the most chilling tales involved budget planning based on three conflicting forecasts: One from finance, one from HR, and one from sales. Naturally, none of them matched, because apparently one forecast would have been too generous.
“I had three different forecasts—one from finance, one from HR, and one from sales,” said a frazzled CMO. “None of them matched.”
Another CMO described how one bad ARR assumption caused a budget to balloon like a cursed jack-o’-lantern. Moore’s advice was refreshingly blunt: “Before building your marketing budget, lock the growth assumptions. Garbage in, garbage out.”
For CMOs, this is credibility protection. If the assumptions are wobbly, the budget will be too. Lock the revenue target, pipeline expectations, hiring plan, and growth model before the spreadsheet starts reproducing.
The best CMOs treat budgets as strategic roadmaps, not mysterious prophecies handed down from Mount Finance.
“We’re asked to justify spending based on what we can deliver,” said one CMO. “So we reverse-engineered the budget from revenue goals.”
Another Huddler added: “Forecasting is a conversation, not a one-way mandate.”
This is the grown-up budgeting conversation. Show what the team can deliver with the resources requested. Show what falls away if the resources disappear. Tie spend to outcomes, not departmental nostalgia. The CFO may still say no, but at least everyone understands what the no costs.
Few questions make a CMO’s soul briefly leave the body like this one: “If we gave you more budget, what would you do with it?”
The right answer is not a dramatic pause followed by “brand.” It is a ranked list of investment options tied to impact, confidence, and timing.
“We know our best-performing channel is paid search,” said one. “Every dollar there returns multiples in pipeline and revenue.”
Another CMO reminded the group that the answer does not always need to be more people: “It’s not always about headcount. Sometimes it’s tools that help us move faster.”
Walk into the finance chamber with your silver bullet: The next best dollar, expected return, timing, constraints, and CAC-to-LTV logic. If the incremental ask is clear, finance can evaluate it. If it is foggy, finance will bring out the axe.
In some companies, marketing budgets are stitched together like Frankenstein’s monster, with pieces owned by sales, product, finance, corporate, and occasionally someone who left in 2022.
“I own B2B marketing and report into Sales. Meanwhile, product marketing, PR, and creative report to product,” said one exasperated CMO. “We have separate budgets and no single CMO.”
Another Huddler summed up the operating problem: “You can’t optimize what you can’t see.”
If marketing-related spend lives in different graveyards, visibility comes first. CMOs need to map the whole spend picture before they can make serious claims about efficiency, duplication, or strategic trade-offs.
Budget season does not have to be a haunted house. Balance people, programs, and technology. Fit the budget to company stage. Lock assumptions. Reverse-engineer from outcomes. Prepare your incremental asks. Map the whole marketing spend picture before trying to optimize it.
The scariest budget is not the lean one. It is the one built on ghosts.
There is no universal ratio. Budget mix should reflect company stage, growth goals, team productivity, technology needs, and program requirements. Startups and mature companies often need very different mixes.
Marketing plans built on conflicting sales, finance, or HR forecasts are unreliable. Agreement on ARR, pipeline, hiring, and growth assumptions prevents budget rework and protects credibility.
Come prepared with ranked incremental investments, expected impact, timing, trade-offs, and confidence levels. Show where each dollar goes and which business metric it should improve.
Map every marketing-related budget across sales, product, finance, corporate, and regional teams. CMOs cannot optimize spend they cannot see.